In his second column of the 2026-27 season, Jump racing expert Matt Tombs assesses the Betfair Chase and John Durkan and their nature as trials (or not) for the Cheltenham Festival.

This latest column is one of the Trials Trails that I began writing last season. They examine the inherent nature of some of the big races of the weekend, partly with a view to finding value in those races but mainly looking at them as trials for the Cheltenham Festival. If we understand the inherent nature of both the upcoming race and the Festival race(s) it’s a trial for, it should help us identify the under-bet horses.
There are many reasons for the Irish dominance of the Cheltenham Festival in recent years, not least of the Gold Cup, which Britain last won with Native River in 2018.
Some are beyond the control of the British industry such as the excellence of leading Irish trainers and the related decisions of many big owners to have most of their best prospects trained in Ireland, (even when they themselves live in Britain.)
However, if looked at through the narrow prism of Festival success there are ways the British industry doesn’t help itself – and this weekend’s Grade One chases illustrate that.
In Ireland the John Durkan was moved from an early-December to a mid-November slot in 2023. Previously horses running in it had often missed the Christmas Festivals as the races were close together. So the John Durkan was moved such that there’s now a natural path to run in both.
The John Durkan is run over 2m3f150y, which I think is not far short of the perfect distance for Gold Cup horses to start the season. It’s also ideal for Ryanair horses, (albeit many are hoped to be Gold Cup horses at this stage.)
Kicking King won both the John Durkan and Gold Cup in the same season
The fortunes of the John Durkan as a Gold Cup and Ryanair trial are really stark. Between 2000 and 2019 the John Durkan produced just two winners at the Festival, Gold Cup winners Kicking King & War Of Attrition. The Ryanair replaced the Cathcart in 2005 and in the first 15 renewals John Durkan runners were 0/15, including four winners.
As power shifted westwards across the Irish Sea, unsurprisingly the record improved. The last four December renewals produced a Gold Cup winner and three Ryanair winners - the John Durkan had already become a key Festival trial before the date was moved.
However, since being run in mid-November its influence has moved up a gear. It’s produced all three Gold Cup winners, two seasons ago the 1-2 and last season the 1-3. It’s also produced the last two Ryanair winners. In those three seasons, the only John Durkan runner not to at least achieve a place when running in the Gold Cup or Ryanair was Fastorslow who unseated in the 2024 Gold Cup.
We’ve only had three November renewals but it wouldn’t surprise me if that trend builds and the John Durkan becomes established as the strongest trial all season in terms of producing Gold Cup and Ryanair winners.
The difficulty is that there is an unusually wide range of fitness on display so the form takes plenty of interpreting - it can therefore also pay to soak up the vibes. If you are an ante-post punter I’d watch and re-watch the John Durkan for clues, (and if you’re not I’d consider becoming one as the value has often been squeezed out of the Open Grade Ones at the Festival by the time declarations are made, with the exception these days of the Stayers Hurdle.)
If anything jumps out at you once you’ve digested Sunday’s race then it may be a good time to strike an ante-post bet. Recent history suggests you’ve probably watched the Gold Cup and/or Ryanair winner.
In terms of the race itself, it had been a very predictable race when run in December with 15 of the 23 winners this century going off favourite or joint-favourite, including six of the last eight. The three November renewals have gone to a 9/1 fourth-favourite of six, 7/2 third-favourite of eight and 13/8 second-favourite of ten.
I’m not expecting regular upsets as I think it’ll be known which runners are blowing the cobwebs away – but it’s a deeper race now despite that and so may not be the favourite-backers paradise it once was.
Watch: Betfair Chase memories: from Kauto Star to Bristol De Mai
Whilst the overall British record in recent Gold Cups is important context, the Betfair Chase seems to have been designed to be a Grade One that minimises the chance of it being a good Festival guide. If it is desired that the Betfair Chase be part of a Grade One pattern building to the Gold Cup, (as opposed to the stand-alone autumn Grade One it mainly is at the moment,) I think the race needs to change.
When it was introduced in 2005, into an era of British dominance, the Betfair Chase was run over 2m6f204y. The distance was increased to 3m24y in 2013 and to 3m1f125y in 2017. Ignoring slight differences in practice between renewals due to dolling out etc, the race is now over 581y further than when Kauto Star and Imperial Commander were contesting it en route to Gold Cup glory the following March.
The ground can get really deep at Haydock. Recent renewals on what was in practice heavy ground won by Royal Pagaille in 2024 and Bristol De Mai in 2020 and 2017 have looked really attritional slogs. Unsurprisingly, those slogs took a toll and runners from those three renewals finished 65FP0PP702 at the Festival.
Since 2017 when it has been run over 3m1f125y, runners in the Gold Cup are 1/21, (A Plus Tard did the double after winning the Betfair Chase in unusually fast conditions). Trainers plan well in advance and so the mere threat of a slog over a long distance in the mud at this stage of the season is enough to point many in a different direction with their Gold Cup horses. It’s no surprise it’s become such a poor Gold Cup guide.
As I understand it, the distance was changed because they used to have to start at or just before a bend. That problem was solved by increasing the distance - now runners begin by jumping the last in the home straight.
My suggestion, if the Betfair Chase is to be seen as part of a pattern leading to the Gold Cup, would be to look at the success of the John Durkan. That isn’t solely down to most of the best chasers being in Ireland – the distance is a big factor too.
Perhaps the start of the Betfair Chase could be at the end of the back straight, so it’s run over what I’d guess would be somewhere between 2m5f-2m6f. (If the priority is instead to have a stand-alone staying ‘championship’ chase in November then it’s fine as it is.)
Affordale Fury is one of several possible Irish runners at Haydock on Saturday
The dry autumn has meant horses have missed their targets, which could strengthen the Betfair Chase this year. Both Affordale Fury and Heart Wood missed the Grade One at Down Royal on account of the ground and could be re-directed to Haydock. So perhaps this year’s renewal will be a bit different - there were a lot of uncertain runners confirmed on Monday.
One of the golden rules of using trends is to acknowledge that they are built on typical renewals of a race – and if you get a renewal that shapes up very differently you should be cautious about those trends. It’s therefore a bit of a watching brief at this stage.
I’d argue that the strongest handicap run all season in terms of being a good guide to the Festival is on Saturday at Haydock, the Betfair Stayers’ Red Rose Handicap Hurdle (3m½f).
Despite only having existed since the 2005/06 season, (for 10 years it was run over fixed brush hurdles and that’s the title many punters still attribute to the race,) it has produced 12 Festival winners. To put that in context, only nine races all season have produced more Festival winners this century and all have been in existence all century.
More importantly from a punting viewpoint is how profitable a trial the Betfair Stayers’ Red Rose Handicap Hurdle has been to follow at the Festival.
Overall runners at the Festival are 12/104 – 130pt (125%) profit. That’s one of the most profitable trials of the season and comfortably the most profitable of those that have produced at least 10 winners. No other handicap, (excluding those that have just produced the odd Festival winner,) has produced even half that profit margin.
Some races are simply good trials for a single, usually obvious, Festival race. Others are just really strong races and so produce winners in lots of different Festival races – and from lots of different finishing positions. This is one of the latter - only one of those 12 Festival winners won at Haydock – Paisley Park en route to the 2019 Stayers’ Hurdle.
Those 12 Festival wins are spread across eight races but six are in the obvious two races, the Pertemps Final (3/41 – 41% profit) and the Stayers’ Hurdle (3/15 – 316% profit).
The three Stayers’ Hurdle winners were all, perhaps unsurprisingly, second season hurdlers. If you’re good enough to win a Stayers’ Hurdle having been running in handicaps earlier in the season it makes sense that you’re an up-and-comer stepping out of novice company. (More generally, don’t underestimate good handicap form in the Stayers’ Hurdle - eight winners this century had contested a handicap earlier that season).
Of those three Stayers’ Hurdle winners, Paisley Park ran off 147 at Haydock, My Way De Solzen off 142 and Lisnagar Oscar off 141. The only second-season hurdler with a similar mark is Matty’s Getaway (141) who looks on a steep upward curve having bolted up at Chepstow last time on only his sixth hurdles start.
The handicap winners at the Festival this has produced have different profiles. Of the three Pertemps winners, Holywell was a second-season hurdler 10lb higher at Cheltenham than Haydock. By contrast, Cape Tribulation was in his fourth season jumping obstacles and was 8lb lower at Cheltenham and Buena Vista was in his fifth season jumping obstacles and was 5lb lower at Cheltenham. (The other two handicap winners, in the BetMGM Cup & Martin Pipe, were 1lb & 5lb lower at Cheltenham respectively.)
My take is that if you are planning an assault on a handicap hurdle at the Festival, (at staying or intermediate trips), this is exactly the sort of race you’d be taking in. It’s a strong event so good match practice, and it’s the sort of form that is pretty solid and reliable in the eyes of the handicapper.
When sifting through the Festival handicap entries in February, looking for runners from the Betfair Stayers’ Red Rose Handicap Hurdle, especially those who have been dropped in the handicap and look to have been campaigned with the Festival in mind, might just find you a Festival winner.

Sizing Europe was the last to win a Craddockstown and Arkle
There are two Grade Two novice chases at Punchestown, the Craddockstown (2m) and the Florida Pearl, (since 2023 over 3m, previously at around 2m6f.)
These races are a good illustration of how training patterns have changed, the Craddockstown in particular. Of the first 14 Arkles this century, three were won by Irish-trained horses. Both Moscow Flyer and Sizing Europe were following up a Craddockstown win. Notably, both were having their third run over fences at Punchestown.
By contrast, of the last three Irish-trained Arkle winners, Kargese and El Fabiolo didn’t begin their chasing careers until December and Gaelic Warrior made his chasing debut in the beginners’ chase at this meeting.
Those three were all trained by Willie Mullins. Different training methodologies impact this. Whilst Gordon Elliott starts his horses earlier than Mullins and so they might have won a beginners’ in time to contest the Craddockstown, Elliott doesn’t specialise in two-mile chasers – and so on.
As a consequence, the better two-mile novices haven’t usually run in their beginners’ early enough to contest the Craddockstown these days. This has led to the Craddockstown rarely being an Arkle trial now. It hasn’t produced a Festival winner since Sizing Europe and the last to be placed in an Arkle was Ordinary World 10 seasons ago.
The Florida Pearl suffers to an extent from the same context – but less so. I think that’s for two reasons. In two-mile chasing there is more emphasis on the raw ability to go a really strong gallop and jump at it. Chasing experience is still a factor but it’s a lesser part of the overall requirement in an Arkle than a Broadway.
The ability to run quickly and jump well is obviously still an important part of three-mile chasing – but stamina, guts and being battle-hardened are big factors too. Horses tend to finish tired over three miles in a way they don’t usually over two. Getting battle-hardened over fences is more of an advantage in a Broadway than an Arkle. There’s therefore more chance a Broadway horse will have run in a beginners’ in time to contest the Florida Pearl. Additionally, Elliott does specialise in three-mile chasers – he’s won six of the last 10 Florida Pearls.

Presenting Percy won the Florida Pearl and then at the Cheltenham Festival
The Florida Pearl has only produced 11 Broadway runners all century but Presenting Percy won and four of the others were placed.
My take is that often the Florida Pearl will suffer from ‘modern early season graded novice race syndrome.’ However, if horses that are good enough to be Broadway contenders are ready to run in the Florida Pearl, they are likely to be arriving at Cheltenham battle-hardened over fences and may provide betting value. Presenting Percy was 5/2 favourite but the four placed horses went off between 9/1 – 22/1.
Interestingly, two years ago Elliott’s Albert Bartlett winner Stellar Story won the Florida Pearl on chasing debut before finishing runner-up in the Broadway. I wonder if that might become a trend.
The change in training methods, from Mullins in particular, has meant plenty of these autumn graded novice races are graded in name only. The beginners’ chases at the moment are more likely to produce Arkle or Broadway winners than the graded novice chases. So why not run your chasing debutant in the graded novice for four times as much prize money and avoid the Mullins A-teamers?
This year Largy Star could make his chasing debut in the Florida Pearl, whilst Generous Risk and Zanoosh could do so in the Craddockstown. All three are also entered in the beginners’ chase on Saturday but there they could be taking on the likes of Mighty Park and Narciso Has.
As well as modern training methods making the beginners’ chases in Ireland at this stage more likely to produce Arkle or Broadway winners than the graded novices, I think the ‘Autumn Festivals’ concept is a factor too.
In the 2023/24 season, the Irish programme was re-arranged to condense a lots of the top races into three consecutive weekends at Navan, Punchestown and Fairyhouse.

Will Mighty Park be the next Closutton superstar? (Pic: Healy Racing)
With so many of the established stars running, (and often beginning their seasons,) over these three weekends, perhaps subconsciously trainers will aim what they hope are their star novices at the maiden hurdles and beginners’ chases on these six cards.
There is some early evidence that is happening with the 2m3f beginners’ chase at Punchestown. Before the Autumn Festival programme was introduced in 2023, the only Festival winner it had produced this century was Finger Onthe Pulse in the Novices’ Handicap Chase, (albeit plenty of winners had run well in defeat in Grade One novice races at the Festival.)
In the three years since, its produced Gaelic Warrior to win the Arkle, Inothewayurthinkin the Kim Muir and Kitzbuhel the Broadway.
As well as suggesting this is now likely to be novice form to follow, the 2m3f trip illustrates another important point. Punters tend to badge horses depending on the trip they’ve run over. Many thought Gaelic Warrior wouldn’t have the speed for an Arkle. There was a question mark over Kitzbuhel’s stamina for the Broadway.
In novice company the star novice will often win at a wide range of trips. There’s only one crop of horses taking them on and the star novice can often outclass them even when the trip isn’t ideal, (as they move into open company the range of distances they can win at usually narrows.)
Don’t fall into the trap of thinking that a winner of a race like this 2m3f beginners’, especially one that then runs only in intermediate trip races like the Faugheen, Killiney or Moriarty before Cheltenham - is some sort of intermediate trip specialist. If they are a top-class novice they may well outclass their opposition in an Arkle or Broadway even if the trip isn’t ideal. Mighty Park looks just that type this season.
Click here to start your free one-month trial!

Watch over 100 live race meetings for FREE! Start your free one-month trial of Racing TV.

Racing TV encourages responsible gambling - to find out more click here to head to our dedicated website page.
New UK customers. Place a £10 real money bet at min. 2.0 odds within 5 days of deposit. Get 4 x £10 Free Bets: 1 Single, 2 Accas & 1 Bet Builder (min. 3 selections each). Excludes cashout, E/W, Multis, Ineligible Markets & Odds Boosts. Credited after bet settlement. 7-day expiry. T&Cs apply. 18+ GambleAware
18+. New UK customers (Excluding NI) only. Min Deposit £10. Min stake £10. Min odds Evs. Free bet applied on 1st settlement of any qualifying bet. 30 days to qualify. Free bets expire in 7 days. Cashed out/Free Bets won’t apply. Account & Payment method restrictions apply. 1 Free Bet offer per customer, household & IP Address only. T&C's apply. 18+. IRE/NI & UK online only. Max Free Bet £/€10. Win or win part of e/w outright singles. 5+ runners. 1st bet on each race. Free/void/antepost bets don't qualify. In event of a dead heat, offer won’t apply. Applies to First Past the Post result. Unnamed 2nd Favs don’t qualify. Acc & Payment restrictions apply. T&Cs apply.
New UK Customers Only. Bet £10+ on any sportsbook markets at odds of evens (2.00) or greater. Get 50% back of your first day’s losses as a Free Bet up to £50, valid for 7 days. 18+ GambleAware.
New Players Only. Free bet - one-time stake of £50, min odds 1.5, stake not returned. 1X wager the winnings. Wager from real balance first. Wager calculated on bonus bets only. Max conversion: £200. Valid for 7 Days from receipt. Limited to 1 sport & 5 casino brand/s within the network. Withdrawal requests void all active/pending bonuses. Excluded Skrill and Neteller deposits. Full Terms apply. #AD *Can only claim one bonus from websites that are part of the ProgressPlay network. Monster Sports is also part of the Progress Play network. 18+ GambleAware
New Customers. Opt in, deposit and bet £10+ on any horse racing markets within 7 days of sign up. Get 3 x £10 Free Bets for set horse racing markets. Bonuses expire in 7 days. T&Cs apply. Please gamble responsibly. 18+ GambleAware